Safety and the Value of Life

When people work along the walls of buildings (yes – like Spiderman) at heights of some 200 feet above the ground (for cleaning, painting, water proofing, netting or any other reason), it is expected that there would be something tied to them (such as a rope) and/ or something put below them (such as a net) that will save them if they fall.

So when you see ten men deftly balancing on casuarina poles that they are also twining into a neat upward growing scaffolding, with only their skill and experience separating them from a smashing end, several storeys down, your heart goes to your mouth!  

The first thoughts that come to mind are “What will happen if they fall? How can the contractor be so irresponsible? Why has the employer not ensured that the contractor provides proper working equipment? Don’t their lives have any value? …”

Location: Mumbai, 13th Feb 2013

I caught the work happening after they had reached 12-13 floors. They had another 8-9 floors to go and I was trying to get them to go no further until they were properly equipped.

Scaffolding scares 1

I first followed the accepted practice for complaints and grievances in the apartment block – I wrote to the society office/ concerned committee members and met the society manager, requesting them to take action. After a few hours I saw that the scaffolding had progressed further up. At times the poles would dangerously sway high above, till they were tied in position. I saw workers balance themselves precariously for a drink of water high in the sky.

Scaffolding scares 2

I decided that I would need to do something on my own. Using my market research skills, I got the contact information of the contractor who was carrying out the job. He told me that workers who do scaffolding work do not generally wear harnesses because it hinders their movement up and down the scaffolding. As if to pacify me, he said that the people who will do the water proofing work (which is the reason why the scaffolding was being put) would be equipped with harnesses. And what if one of these scaffolding men fell? It didn’t take long for him to admit that they should have been wearing harnesses and he said he would instruct them to do so immediately.

To follow this up, I quickly went to the work site to talk to the workers. There I saw one harness carelessly lying with the stacked up poles. I asked the two workers who were nearest the ground, why they weren’t wearing the harnesses. And they told me that it makes their work take longer because they need to keep un-fastening and fastening the harness clips as they move up. And if you fall? “We won’t fall”, he said. Hopefully not. I told them that I’d talked to their big boss, and he had agreed that they should wear the harnesses from tomorrow (it was already close to the end of the day’s work).

Just as a bike rider wears a helmet even after riding for 20 years, I told them it was important for them to be safe in case of an accident. I tried to explain to them that they shouldn’t be relying on their skill and luck to get them home safe to their families at the end of the day. Don’t they value their lives? Forget the extra time the harness takes, if they fall it will be the end of time! Then I heard one of the men telling the other that they should take out the harnesses (from the store room) the next day. They talked in Telugu so I talked back to them in Telugu telling them “tomorrow, no harness, no work”. They were delighted and asked where I was from. When I said Bangalore, one of them started talking in Kannada saying he was from Gulbarga. Before leaving, I reminded them that from tomorrow they were going to wear the harnesses, not to satisfy me or anyone else in the building, but for themselves and their families.

As receivers of various services, each one of us can do our bit in ensuring that our service providers and their workers make no compromises when it comes to their safety. And go a bit further in making them realise that their lives are precious.


Update: 14th Feb 2013

When I met the men (boys really – most of them look like they’re in their late teens or early twenties) this morning, it was so good to see all of them wearing harnesses. The whole lot is Kannada speaking so I could interact quite easily with them. I told them how happy I was to see them wear the harness. Also mentioned that wearing it on ones person was not enough, but each needed to tie/ clip it to ensure that it holds in case of a slip or a fall.

They introduced me to their “Maistry” (supervisor), a slight man in his late years who said he was happy that someone thought about “safety” (it’s called safety in all languages!) and got around the boys to wear the harnesses.

Yesterday’s scaffolding was completed by the end of the day so today, a new scaffolding on a different wall in is progress. I hope the workers will remember to keep themselves safe as they move up. After all, as one of the boys said, “It is for our safety only. Now we know.”

Harnessed to be safe

7 thoughts on “Safety and the Value of Life

  1. bhaskar February 14, 2013 / 7:22 am

    I share your feelings on this topic. I have a couple of small projects that I do and my workers wear helmets, harness safety shoes. But I am told they wear them only when they see me enter the site…most times they don’t. This is despite the fact that I have told them I would rather kick them out and keep the site safe rather than risk someone falling. Value for human life is very minuscule, unfortunately even in front of the workers eyes.


  2. Austin February 14, 2013 / 11:38 am

    Underdstand your feelings Arathi. I would like to know about what happened next day. Did they wear harnesses and what was your reaction.


  3. Arathi Manay February 14, 2013 / 12:41 pm

    Yes Bhaskar. I think education is the key. I’ve updated my post with today’s happenings.


  4. Arathi Manay February 14, 2013 / 12:42 pm

    Austin, I’ve updated my post with today’s happenings.


  5. Krishna October 19, 2013 / 6:04 pm

    you are quite an amazing person to have taken the trouble to follow up and educate the workers. So many of us are concerned but do nothing about it.


  6. Arathi Manay October 19, 2013 / 8:37 pm

    Thanks for saying this Krishna. Every drop does make a difference, at some point in time.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s